Moral dilemma
Steve Irwin died on film. There is now a debate going on about whether this footage should be shown to the public (BBC story here). What do you think?
Steve was a showman. He lived on the edge because he understood animals and their behaviour really well. His message was about the power of animals and the respect that they deserve. His accident proved that whatever knowledge you have and precautions you take, nature is a wild phenomena. His death proved what he was saying all along. It almost seems like the natural conclusion to what he wanted to teach us. In that respect, this final chapter in Steve's life should be broadcast as a warning, a conclusion and celebration.
On the other hand, Steve's long time friend and producer John Stainton says the tape should be destroyed. At this time I am unsure what his wife thinks but presumably, her wishes take top priority. As a potential viewer, what would be my motives in watching what I would know were the last moments of a man's life? Voyerism surely?
On balance, I think that we shouldn't view the tape. I would be interested in hearing your thoughts on the matter...
posted by Helsalata @ 9:49 am
2 comments
2 Comments:
Think I'm with you too Helen. I wondered when this issue would surface as I heard of his death.
Many people will be interested to find out more about the event. After all stingrays are said to be quite timid. But we must remember the consequences, a wife left without her husband and two children now fatherless. If this sad event were to be broadcast to millions it would surely impact them. For instance, would it be a one off viewing or would it roll around every couple of years (for training purposes)? If so, how could they get closure?
Additionally,if it were broadcast the film producers may lose control of the footage. It would be easy enough for someone to record it.
For me this seems a step to far.
Hi there Im new to this!
This is a serious issues for steves family,but i read to day that there maybe plans for his 8 year old daughter to continue the film and help complete this piece of work.
I hope this is not true and its just the tabliod newspapers trying to continue media interest in this story, and sell a few more papers!
the family need support and help to deal with their sad loss in private. Im totally against steves 8 year old daughter fininshing the film.the experience may be more damaging than healing for her.........duty of care should be the priority for the children not finishing a tv programme!
Post a Comment
<< Home